Methods, systems, and computer-readable storage media for proxy re-encryption of encrypted data stored in a first database of a first server and a second database of a second server. Implementations include actions of receiving a first token at the first server from a client-side computing device, providing a first intermediate re-encrypted value based on a first encrypted value and the first token, transmitting the first intermediate re-encrypted value to the second server, receiving a second intermediate re-encrypted value from the second server, the second intermediate re-encrypted value having been provided by encrypting the first encrypted value at the second server based on a second token, providing the first encrypted value as a first re-encrypted value based on the first intermediate re-encrypted value and the second intermediate re-encrypted value, and storing the first re-encrypted value in the first database.