A computer-implemented method may include monitoring a computing system for evidence of potential data failures within the computing system. The computer-implemented method may also include detecting evidence that indicates a potential data failure while monitoring the computing system and identifying data implicated in the potential data failure based on the detected evidence. The computer-implemented method may further include initiating an action configured to proactively facilitate restoration of at least a portion of the data implicated in the potential data failure prior to determining whether the data implicated in the potential data failure needs to be restored. Various other methods, systems, and computer-readable media are also disclosed.