A system and method for transferring bill payment data whereby a user identifies their current financial institution and provides authentication data associated with their current online account system. The current online account system is then accessed using the user provided current online account system authentication data and data associated with a bill payment feature, and/or recurring bill payment feature, of the current online account system is obtained and/or copied, in one example using screen scraping technology. The data associated with the bill payment feature, and/or recurring bill payment feature, of the current online account system is displayed to the user and the user is provided the opportunity to select what portions of the data are to be transferred to a bill payment feature, and/or recurring bill payment feature, of the a new online account system. The selected data then transferred to the bill payment feature, and/or recurring bill payment feature, of the new online account system.