The present disclosure involves systems, software, and computer implemented methods for automatically modifying a payment instrument type of a user. One example method comprises receiving, via a communications module, a first signal including an indication of acceptance associated with a particular product selected from a set of potential products for replacing a current product associated with a first customer. At least one term or condition associated with the selected product is identified that is different than the terms or conditions associated with the at least one current product. The terms and conditions associated with the at least one current product associated with the first customer are automatically modified to correspond with the at least one different identified term or condition associated with the selected product, wherein modifying the terms or conditions does not change a unique identifier associated with the at least one current product being modified.