A method, an information handling system (IHS) and a memory mirroring system for operating a mirrored memory. The method includes detecting, via a memory controller, at least one uncorrectable data error (UCDE) in a first memory device. In response to detecting the at least one UCDE, a UCDE event counter is retrieved that tracks the number of UCDE events that have occurred and a UCDE event threshold is retrieved corresponding to a maximum number of allowed UCDE events. The method further includes determining if the UCDE event counter is greater than the UCDE event threshold and in response to determining that the UCDE event counter is not greater than the UCDE event threshold, continuing writing of data to the first memory device via a first memory channel and continuing writing of the data to a second memory device via a second memory channel to create a mirror of the data.