Systems and methods are provided for managing data across a network based on multiple keys assigned to different participants in association with the data. One exemplary method includes identifying, by an originating party, a relying party, identifying data relevant to at least one interaction between the originating party and the relying party, and encrypting the data based on a secret. The method also includes generating a key set based on the secret, where the key set has at least three keys and is structured such that the secret is derivable from at least two of the at least three keys, and disseminating a first key of the key set and the encrypted data to a control party and disseminating a second key of the key set to the relying party.